The Roar
The Roar

Rahul Deepak Kumar

Roar Rookie

Joined November 2023

14.8k

Views

29

Published

10

Comments

Published

Comments

Admittedly I am very young, well past EJ’s time so it would be difficult to compare the eras. As always, this is a subjective. For me, just seeing what Bont has done and the way he continues to amaze me, puts him up there however it may very be a different story if I was lucky enough to see EJ

Is Marcus Bontempelli the greatest to ever don the red, white and blue?

Whilst you make some good points, I think we need to be cautious about overreacting to one bad performance. The dogs are one of the most lethal teams in the air and with the Swans injuries, they were always gonna be challenged in the air. Whilst McDonald and McLean are not the best tall targets, they still give them good representation and it’d be better to holistically rate them after a few more games.

Questions to ponder ahead of Round 21: Can Swans stop slump, Will Jamarra stay hot and is Mabior Chol in career-best form?

Absolutely Lefau has been on of the few shining lights for Tigers. Absolutely gutted he’s gone down. However they’d have some key personnel returning which may help their chances.

Questions to ponder ahead of Round 13: Which McKay brother will prevail, Can Pies bolster midfield and Can Tigers scare the Crows?

Thank you!!

Round 11 questions to ponder: Can Dockers prove top-eight credentials, will Suns stay hot, can Eagles win away?

How will Carlton kick through this impregnable Dees defence?
For the last 3 years, the Dees have had arguably the best defence in the competition with solid rebounders in Jake Lever, Steven May and more recently Tom McDonald who played a crucial role on Jeremy Cameron last week, freeing up Lever and May to play the interceptor role.
Whilst Geelong has a very potent forward line, the Demons restricted them to a mere 66 points, with both Jeremy Cameron and Tom Hawkins going goalless as the Cats were simply unable to bypass the Dees setup behind the ball effectively.
This would be a major concern for Michael Voss and Carlton on Thursday night given the Blues struggles to connect effectively forward due to an overdependence on main key talls in Charlie Curnow and Harry McKay.
Carlton simply has to find a way to diversify their ball movement beyond kicking long to Curnow and McKay otherwise you’d suspect the Dees defence will be able to negate these two talls and therefore make scoring very difficult for the Blues.

Questions to ponder ahead of Round 9: Can Hawkins reverse form, are Dons finals contenders and how will Harley go against Pies?

True Pearce is having a fantastic year! You cant really expect Weitering to stop all 3 of Amiss, Treacy and Taberner??

Questions to ponder ahead of Round 5: Are we sleeping on the Cats, Will West Coast's pain continue and How good are the Dees' forwards?

Whoops ???? didn’t realise that mistake, was so caught up in his good performance against Freo. Thanks for calling that out

Questions to ponder ahead of Round 5: Are we sleeping on the Cats, Will West Coast's pain continue and How good are the Dees' forwards?

That’s the other thing, I didn’t quite get to mention here. Their midfield looks amazing and it’ll be interesting to see their mix and how they use Fyfe and O’Meara

We're only three games in... but is this the year that Freo fans can finally dream of Flagmantle?

They just have so many, its crazy and impossible to list them all!! Best kicking team in the comp

Questions to ponder ahead of Round 3: Can the Pies be re-heated, Are Port the real deal, Can Jezza's form last for the Cats?

Ok but can we please appreciate Merrett. He personified the ‘edge’ or whatever you wanna call it and actually played a very good game of football. More of Essendon need to follow him in actually embodying this competitiveness in actual play

'The Essendon Edge': The Bombers are trying to fake it until they make it